Pastors and Creatives – Can’t We All Just Get Along?

If you read this blog at all, you know that I’m constantly challenging artists to create great art, and to become bigger people. But in this brief post, I want to talk directly to the pastors and leaders who find themselves in positions of authority over artists and creatives.

For a recent interview, I was asked a really great question:

What’s one thing that pastors and church leaders can do to facilitate a stronger relationship with the artists and creatives under their care?

My answer is easy to say, and complex to enact.

I think pastors need to clearly communicate the scope and the vision of the project to the artists involved.

Scope.

Vision.

Those two things.

The scope and vision of a project can happen as a result of some executive staff meeting, a brainstorm meeting, or some crazy middle-of-the-night idea. But regardless of its genesis, the pastor needs to communicate the scope and vision PRIOR to the artist picking up pen, paintbrush, or software.

I cannot tell you how frustrating it is to create art (music, video, print pieces, stage elements, lighting, sound, etc.), without knowing the vision or the scope.

Please know this about any great artist – They will throw their hearts and minds and off-days into their art with every new project they’re handed. They can’t help doing that. Creativity isn’t limited to 9 hours during their days.

But for many, they do this based on an educated guess, always knowing that they might be wrong when the first-draft reveal happens. There’s a difference between art that doesn’t meet an artistic standard, and art that’s wrong.

Tweaking something in the revision process is great and expected – it’s needed to create great and collaborative art. I tweak stuff all day, every day for great clients. But changing the scope or vision over and over again is not great, and not expected.

And churches will lose artists if scope and vision changes become the norm. 

Pastors are creating environments. They cannot help but create environments. My deepest prayer is that their environments are both professionally challenging and spiritually life-giving. The artists I meet are fine with the first part, but really really really need the second part.

What about you? How can pastors and senior leaders improve their relationships with the artists and creative folks in their care?

__________________
Hello there! If you are new here, you might want to subscribe to the RSS feed for updates from this blog. In addition, please check out my book that talks about this stuff in more depth.
  • http://ww.journeyofworship.com Chris Gambill

    Great thoughts, Gary. I would also add the following to how pastors/senior leaders can improve their relationships with the artists:
    1) Allow them to actually do the work of creating. Once the necessary scope and vision are defined, then let the artists create. Don't create for them. Engage them in the dialogue and trust their creative instincts.
    2) Invest in them as people. Disciple and care for them. Learn to speak to them with grace and truth.
    3) Have their back. If something doesn't work or the "important" family in the church doesn't care for something, don't throw them under the bus.

    • http://Www.BrianCrum.com Brian Crum

      Chris, you definitely nailed that one. I can’t tell you how many times I have experienced AND seen the “important” family/families destroy churches by their disapproval. And the worst part is: the pastor all too often does throw the Creative under the bus or claims he “didn’t know.”

  • http://Www.BrianCrum.com Brian Crum

    Gary… brother… thank you for this reminder.

    Creativity is exactly that: creative. It’s art and it’s motion. It’s beautiful when unmuddled and pure.

    Thanks again, man!